The problem with plastic is a global epidemic that follows you throughout your day. It is very likely that you are using plastic right now. Cell phones made with polycarbonate, clothes made of polyester, and shoes made with polyurethane — all of these materials are plastic.
In Canada, it is estimated that 3.3 million tonnes of plastic waste is produced per year. Most of which will end up in landfills, significantly impacting the environment and wildlife. The Government of Canada says that if current trends continue, the ocean could reach a 1:1 weight ratio of plastic to fish by 2050. Concerned for the health of our planet, large and small-scale efforts have been made to come up with solutions to this ever-growing plastic problem. One major solution, some say, could be the implementation of bioplastic.
Compared to regular plastic, which is typically petroleum-based, bioplastics are made of biological or renewable resources. Under the right conditions, these materials can be compostable or made to be biodegradable.
The inability of regular plastic to decompose quickly is a major problem, sometimes taking thousands of years to break down. New research has found that even with immediate action put into reducing plastic waste, there could still 710 million metric tons of plastic in the environment by 2040.
“The main advantage of bioplastics is that they support the sustainable carbon cycle, therefore reducing the CO2 that is released in the atmosphere, compared to the traditional petroleum-based plastics,” says Dr. Amar K. Mohanty, professor, and Ontario Agriculture College distinguished research chair in sustainable biomaterials at the University of Guelph.
Other advantages, Mohanty says, include the ability of bioplastic to reduce the carbon footprint, reduce the dependency of fossil fuel resources, and the capacity of some bioplastics to be degraded under appropriate environmental conditions.
To support industries interested in manufacturing products using bioplastic, companies like NaturePlast have been creating a range of alternative solutions to regular plastic. Founded in 2007, NaturePlast states that their materials can be used in a wide variety of sectors including cosmetic packaging, pet supplies, and construction. Other companies specializing in bioplastics, like Green Dot Bioplastic and Vegeplast advertise their products as compostable and biodegradable, but there is a catch.
Just because a product is advertised as a bioplastic does not mean it is biodegradable. Mohanty explains the term “bioplastic” can be defined as a two-way strategy. The first is a bioplastic that is biobased. These plastics are derived from biological material like corn, shells, or plant oil. The second type is a bioplastic that is biodegradable; meaning the plastic can be broken down into natural substances like water and carbon dioxide. Sometimes, however, bioplastics can also be both.
To make things even more complicated, Mohanty says that even biodegradable plastic might not be biodegradable in every environment.
“It sounds confusing to people because the public understands that biodegradable plastic means it is biodegradable everywhere, but that is not right. Biodegradable plastic must be degraded in a particular environment.”
Although many companies can produce both biobased and biodegradable products, it is still up to the consumer to ensure that they are disposing their bioplastic waste properly. For the bioplastic to fulfill its purpose, proper disposal is essential, otherwise bioplastic waste can still end up in a landfill.
State of the Planet says that when deprived of oxygen, bioplastics left in landfills may release methane, a greenhouse gas 23 times more potent than carbon dioxide. Because bioplastics can be made of different materials, not all bioplastics should be disposed of in the same way.
“Many people claim that petroleum-based plastics are recyclable. But imagine if you do not have the recycling facilities for that plastic or the plastic is not recycled,” says Mohanty. “It will become pollution, and it will go to the landfill or the incinerator. In my opinion, bioplastic and even petroleum-based plastic, all should have an end of life. Meaning, they need to be discarded in the proper environment.”
To evaluate the environmental impact of a product, it is necessary to look at each stage of a product’s life — this is called the lifecycle analysis.
“It is a wonderful tool to assess if the value of plastic is good for the environment, or if it is worse than the original plastic,” says Karen Stoeffler, a senior research officer for the National Research Council of Canada. Broken down into four parts (materials, manufacturing, use, and disposal) Stoeffler explains that the lifecycle analysis looks at the overall impact of a product, not just one stage.
“When you are talking about a biobased material, what you are doing is trying to reduce the environmental footprint at the very beginning, at the materials stage,” says Stoeffler. “You are trying to use renewable resources instead of fossil resources, that is one of the big advantages of biobased plastics. When you are talking about biodegradable, you are talking about the disposal.”