 |
magazine / so98
 |
September/October 1998 issue |
|
|
 |
EDITOR'S NOTEBOOK
Beyond the horizon
Dwell in the shadow of a mountain long enough and the
desire to know the other side grows into an obsession.
The eye projects the imagination beyond all horizons.
Early Irish Christians believed the land toward the
sunset was peopled with saints and other holy men. Journeying
toward it was an act of faith, as Saint Brendan and
17 fellow monks were said to have done in a skin-covered
boat in the sixth century. Early Irish literature offers
several dozen versions of the Navigato, which many believe
is a recounting of an actual sea journey Brendan made
to the coast of North America. In the 1970s, British
writer Tim Severin studied the Navigato, constructed
a skin-covered vessel based on ancient Irish boat-building
techniques and sailed it across the North Atlantic to
Newfoundland. His remarkable voyage, described in a
compelling book, The Brendan Voyage, showed not that
Brendan had made such a journey, but that it could be
done.
An
act of imagination. Historical reconstructions all proceed
from an act of imagination. For his new book, The Farfarers,
which is excerpted in this issue, Farley Mowat did not
construct his own skin boat. But his speculations about
a people he believes preceded the Vikings to North America
well before the year 1000 are based on a broad understanding
of early European history, a careful reading of ancient
texts ranging from Norse sagas to the writings of medieval
Irish monks, a sailor's appreciation of the perils of
the North Atlantic, and a 30-year obsession with a story
whose outlines lie beyond the horizon of recorded history.
The tale he fashions from these sources is plausible.
The people he calls the Albans undoubtedly had the navigation
and boat-building skills to have sailed from the British
Isles to Canada. Severin proved that. What no one knows
is whether they did make such journeys and whether they
ever established any settlements here. In what are the
most contentious sections of the book, Mowat argues
that physical evidence of an Alban presence exists in
the form of some 45 mysterious longhouse stone foundations
found on Quebec's Ungava Peninsula and in the High Arctic.
Mowat knows this book will be greeted with great skepticism
within the academic community. He says it is "subjective,
imaginative" and was written unfettered by the constraints
of peer-reviewed science. His hope is that a vigorous
debate about this theory will shake loose research funds
for new archeological field work in the Arctic, northern
Quebec, Newfoundland and Labrador. Look for responses
from archeologists, historians and readers in upcoming
issues.
The worms-for-bait industry is slippery,
shady and, well, a can of worms. Writer Allen Abel pried
it open for us and discovered few people willing to
talk on the record about a business worth an estimated
$50 million a year. When he completed the story, his
manuscript was handed to photographer Peter Sibbald,
who spent weeks attempting to locate the elusive pickers.
Although he was misled several times, he eventually
found a group and spent the night gingerly photographing
them. At dawn they gathered to load and sort their worms.
Sibbald asked for permission to photograph this part
of the operation. Several abruptly turned on him."They
belted me a couple of times," he said, "and demanded
my film. One of them lunged at me and smashed my camera." The
suddenness of the violence stunned everyone and Sibbald
managed an escape. He called the police and they invited
him to press charges. He declined. Sibbald spent other,
less eventful nights in the field and did manage to
find pickers who reluctantly agreed to be photographed
if their faces were covered.
Sibbald's photos illustrate in stark
terms the key point of Abel's story: this is an industry
erected on the backs of a nighttime labour force operating
largely beyond the scrutiny of tax authorities. The
work is so tough and so weather-dependent that the people
who are attracted to it are, for the most part, the
economically desperate. Like people who live in the
shadow of a mountain, those who collect taxes can only
imagine income-earning activity they cannot see. Abel's
story and Sibbald's photos should dispel any illusions
that pickers are getting rich in this shadowy industry.
— Rick Boychuk
top
|
 |
|