magazine / jf11
Reverberations
Required reading
The article “Still waiting” (December
2010), about the appalling state of
education for the children of the Cree
community of Attawapiskat, Ont., left me
outraged. I am a Canadian citizen living
in Oregon, and a teacher of 31 students in
the fourth and fifth grades. I am usually
extremely proud to be Canadian, and I
have continually promoted Canada, but
now my enthusiasm is dampened and I
am quite embarrassed. As an educator,
I am outraged that this situation has con -
tinued for so many years without resolve.
I respectfully request and strongly
encourage a personal and public commitment
from Prime Minister Stephen
Harper that plans for a new school will be
an immediate priority and that immediate
action will be taken to break ground on a
state-of-the-art building. The children of
Attawapiskat deserve as good an education
as any child anywhere in Canada, or
the world. Enough is enough.
Colleen Hallas
Gresham, Oregon
The article on the plight of the
children of Attawapiskat is heartbreaking,
especially after hearing about
the substantial wages, travel expenses
and honoraria paid to elected native band
politicians in Canada [listed in federal
documents obtained by the Canadian
Taxpayers Federation].
Indian and Northern Affairs Canada
has been a mess for many years. I hope the
Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern
Development has the courage and commitment
to change this department for
the betterment of all First Nations. But
I would not hold my breath waiting. The
answer then-Minister Chuck Strahl gave to a 13-year-old child
who had guts enough
to challenge him was
so degrading that he
should be ashamed.
Robert Lovell
Tofield, Alta.
The story about Attawapiskat is a heartfelt
and truthful tale of government
neglect and lost opportunity. The photography
underscores with blinding clarity
the evidence of broken promises and the
indomitable hope and resilience that this
northern Cree community demonstrates.
Public school board trustees in Ontario
have joined the Shannen’s Dream campaign
and will continue to advocate for fair
and equitable educational opportunities for
First Nations children. It is shameful that
children in Attawapiskat and many other
First Nations communities live with the
negative consequences of systemic inequality.
Our provincial schools receive more
funding to educate a First Nations student
than on-reserve First Nations schools do.
Congratulations to Canadian
Geographic for outstanding coverage of
the profound challenges that continue
to face our First Nations communities.
This article should be required reading
for every government representative with
responsibility for this situation and who,
10 years on, continues to fail these children
and their families.
Catherine Fife
President, Ontario Public
School Boards’ Association
Toronto
Grave heart
“Snowed under” (“In habitat,” December
2010) by Leah Sandals hit home with
me. I clearly remember going through the
same experience when I visited my parents’
gravesite last winter. Unerringly, I walked
to their grave. Sandals is right: it’s impossible
to forget. I suspect her article tugged at
a lot of heartstrings.
Drew Preston
Dartmouth, N.S.
Supply and demands
The article “Water for a dry land”
(October 2010) by Allan Casey
addresses important issues that need
further investigation. Unpredictable
weather resulting from climate change
has severely reduced our ability to
forecast the water supply originating
from the eastern slopes of the Rocky
Mountains. Past research has shown
how we can increase water supply during
peak flow through forest management,
notably by using different harvesting
patterns. Other studies have taught us
how to maintain functioning ecosystems
by considering environmental impacts
in coordination with society’s demands.
Scientists are starting to understand
what questions to ask to improve water
management in the Prairie provinces. As
a student of forest management, I support
Casey’s call for more hydrological
research on the eastern slopes, based on
the fact that better understanding leads
to improved management decisions.
Sara Bence
Alberta School of Forest
Science & Management
University of Alberta
Edmonton
The only way to adapt to climate
change is to seriously reduce greenhouse-
gas emissions. Anything else is a
waste of time. Using more fossil fuels
and concrete to buttress our infrastructure
is a mug’s game that will have to be
repeated as the effects of man-made climate
change accelerate. Using revenue
now from non-renewable energy sources
to fund the necessary transition to
renewable sources is how we must adapt.
Mike Bray
Indian Head, Sask
top
* Letters may be edited for length, accuracy and liability.
|